Fresh Dirt - Our latest garden finds, ideas and what to do now.

« It's just smoke: what's the problem? | MAIN | My own little splurge »

Posted by Sunset, July 17, 2008 in Furnishing the garden , Hardscape

By Lisa Albert for Sunset Magazine

I fall in love easily—with gardens and plants, that is. When touring a garden, admiration and joy grows with each step I take and with each plant I discover. Unfortunately, that bliss fades abruptly when I stumble upon the latest must-have garden addition: the wood-burning fire feature.

The haze of second-hand smoke obscures the view. 

I have asthma, along with 22.9 million other Americans. It is the leading chronic childhood illness in the U.S. Although asthma can be fatal, thankfully deaths are infrequent. But it is an expensive disease, costing the U.S. economy around $19.7 billion each year (American Lung Association).

Smoke is a powerful trigger; avoidance of it shapes my life. I’ve given up activities that brought me joy, including camping with my family, for what is camping without a campfire? I’ve accepted these limitations but I’m struggling with those imposed by smoke from recreational fires.

In the last four years, I’ve had to give up time in my garden and shut my windows to cool night breezes due to wood smoke in the neighborhood. I can’t see the fire burning in someone’s backyard whether it’s next door, down the street, or two blocks over. I have no warning that my next breath will include smoke’s deadly particles, and then it’s too late to prevent an attack. Four weeks ago, a neighbor’s smoky fire triggered an attack so severe I thought I’d need hospitalization. It took me four miserable days to recover.

Most people aren’t aware of wood smoke’s impact on air quality, its effect on health and wellbeing, or that these inefficient wood-burning features are a growing source of pollution throughout the U.S. “Each fire emits close to one pound of smoke pollution, with 90% being in the deadly smaller than one micron range.” (Clean Air Revival). Municipalities are banning these polluting features. In many areas, when a fire or its smoke endangers another’s health or property, it is deemed “hostile” and local authorities will extinguish the fire (enforcement agencies vary by region). That certainly would put a damper on an evening of fun around a fire with family and friends. 

The good news is that there are cleaner-burning alternatives, including natural gas, propane, denatured alcohol, and Java-Log.  Even better, the first three options open up a world of design possibilities for our gardens.  Instead of the ubiquitous metal bowl with last night’s charred remains, imagine an artful piece crafted of metal and stone. By day, it is a stunning, creative garden feature. When lit at night, it surprises, pleases, and warms guests without masking intoxicating garden fragrances, such as star jasmine, gardenia, and angel’s trumpet. 

Fortunately, we can have our fire and clean air, too.

Squawvalley1_2

This spectacular feature, designed by Michelle Derviss and built by Miguel Chavez, http://dervissdesign.com/ was crafted for a Squaw Valley, California couple actively involved with environmental causes such as solar power, and green building. Local granite was used for the propane fire ring and the surrounding sitting area. Mountain IronWorks crafted the metal sculpture in the fire ring and the metal privacy screen behind the ring of stone seating. Photo by Michelle Derviss.

P6053200ppt_2 Because propane-fueled flames pose no spark danger, Tom and Barb Eckman of Tualatin, Oregon could safely convert an existing corner flower box on their cedar deck into this fabulous fireplace.  Tom designed and built it using a propane ring and log kit from a local sporting and outdoor goods store, slate tile, and black Mexican pebbles. Photo by Gordon Hickey.

Comments

Great post, Lisa. I think the majority of fire pits in Southern California are gas-fueled. And now that I've read your posts I'm glad.

Posted by:sharon | July 17, 2008 at 08:16 AM

Thank you, Sharon!

I hope it's not long before more switch to gas or another clean-burning source in my region. One of the reasons many opt for wood-burning features is concern about global climate change. I share that concern, however, clean air is just as important. And the climate change impact may not be as great as many think. Tom Eckman estimates that he can get 20 hours of fire from his 5 lb propane tank. They use between 1 and 2 tanks a year. That's comparable to what most use for their barbecues.

Posted by:Lisa Albert | July 17, 2008 at 10:33 AM

Sharon, where are my manners? Sunset writer and editor Lauren Bonar Swezey deserves credit, too. It was her editing assistance that helped make this a great post. Thank you, Lauren!

Posted by:Lisa Albert | July 17, 2008 at 12:19 PM

Oh come on people. Just don't go around fire if it bothers you that much. I doubt that the smell of smoke from a backyard firepit a block away is going to send anyone in to a asthma attack as serious as the one described in this blog. And four days to recover? get real. I am a true outdoor person and there is nothing that I enjoy more than a family BBQ with the fire pit blazin'.

Posted by:smokey d bear | July 17, 2008 at 01:14 PM

Dear Sunset,
Thank you for this educational article.
It may take some time for folks to understand the environmental and medical repercussions of wood burning smoke.
Education is key.
Thanks for trying to inform and elevate the publics awareness.

Posted by:Michelle Derviss | July 17, 2008 at 04:56 PM

I am sure that Smokey d Bear doesn't have friends or family members with asthma. Yes, indeed, an asthma attack can and does occur with this suddenness and seriousness as a result of smoke... be it from campfires, wood stoves or cigarettes. I have also experienced an attack as bad as that described, in fact twice - once from campfire smoke, and once from those cute little colored-smoke-bomb fireworks that used to be sold. As a landscape designer, when a client wants a fire pit I recommend the clean-burning varieties and now will point them to this article.

Thank you, Sunset, Lisa and all for this.

Carol

Posted by:Carol | July 19, 2008 at 06:58 PM

Smokey D Bear, I'm glad you're able to enjoy your BBQ fires. Imagine how much you'd enjoy them if you were unable to draw a breath.

Believe me, someone with asthma does not need to be next to a fire in order to have an attack from the smoke--all that's needed is to inhale the particulates from smoke coming from a fire a distance away. All it takes is one partical of whatever the sufferer is allergic to, to trigger an attack. Asthma is a very serious, very real illness, and yes, the attacks may require hospitalization. And yes, it may take several days to recover from an attack. I also suffer from asthma, and I've taken 3 or 4 days to recover from an attack.

Everything LisaA posted in the blog is right on, with no exaggerations.

Posted by:SnowOwl | July 20, 2008 at 12:36 PM

Kudos on including Michelle Derviss's design. Love all her stuff.
From an admiring peer,
Shirley Bovshow

Posted by:Shirley Bovshow | July 24, 2008 at 12:10 PM

Thank you, Michelle, Carol and SnowOwl, for your support and praise of the educational information in my blog post. Except for Sunset magazine, I have not seen other publications address this issue. That's unfortunate because it's important knowledge readers should have as they make garden design decisions.

Jim posted a great example of art blended with fire today, http://freshdirt.sunset.com/2008/07/fire-water-eart.html
Now that's what I'm talking about! Kathy Swehla's incredible vision and masterful hand combined design elements skillfully, resulting in a beautiful garden.

I'm with you, Shirley - Michelle's designs are gorgeous.

Posted by:Lisa Albert | July 24, 2008 at 03:36 PM

Thanks for this piece. I have asthma and I am constantly having to explain that what is "harmless" on the surface to most people congests me to the point where I wonder if I will lose the ability to draw a breath.

I have had to close windows. Avoid enjoyable activities. Mr. Smokey is lucky to not know what it is like but at the same time he could be a little more compassionate.

Posted by:annie | August 02, 2008 at 08:02 AM
Post a comment


 

Search This Blog
Advertisement