Fresh Dirt - Our latest garden finds, ideas and what to do now.

« Pretty new coreopsis from Terra Nova | MAIN | Green radicchio and floppy quinoa »

Posted by Sunset, July 26, 2009 in Ornamentals , People , Places , Techniques

By Sharon Cohoon, Sunset senior garden writer

If you want to grow anything you want, including roses, in an area, like Cambria, California, where deer roam the neighborhoods like stray cats, there is no substitute for a good tall fence.  But sometimes tall fences don't look right.  Around a small front yard, for instance.  So here's what you do in that case, says deer-resistant landscaping expert Shana McCormick of Great Gardens, who helped homeowners Julie and Monty Rice create the front yard garden shown below.

IMG_9200ed1


1.  Find a list of deer-resistant plants. Study it, decide what you like, make preliminary selections, and then go test them against reality, says Shana.  Walk or drive your neighborhood and see if any of the plants you've selected are doing well in other gardens. Also observe what is thriving, despite deer, that wasn't on your list.  The plants deer will or won't eat varies considerably from neighborhood to neighborhood, Shana has observed. Sometimes even old reliables like rosemary aren't safe.

(Some of the plants used in the garden above, and obviously thriving, are sweet-pea bush (Polygala x dalmaisiana), society garlic, bush germander (Teucrium fruticans), lavender, lamb's ears, and Coleonema.)

2.  Revise your list and trial all the plants you intend to use in quantity.  Buy the largest specimens available to give them a fighting chance, suggests Shana, and test them for at least two weeks.  Tweak your list again.

3.  Now you can plant.  Again, buy the largest specimens you can find, says Shana, and plant in the rainy season if you can when deer aren't so hungry and thirsty.  For further protection, just while plants are getting started, Shana puts out blood meal or Liquid Fence.

4.  Water plants just enough to keep them healthy.  Lush foliage of almost any kind is irresistible to thirsty deer, says Shana.  This is especially important with natives, she says.  "I know deer aren't supposed to eat things like ceanothus or coffeeberry, but they devour them in residential gardens when they're young," she says. "I love natives, but find them hard to get established unless I grow them especially hard."

Another view of the Rice garden:

IMG_9169ed1

You can learn more deer-proofing techniques from Shana McCormick at the class on the subject she'll be teaching at Cambria Nursery on November 29th.

Shana McCormick, Great Gardens, (805) 927-1749

Comments

For years the deer avoided my mophead hydranges. Then one year they destroyed mine and all those in the neighborhood. For years the deer would not think of touching the (zonal)geraniums. One year they were decimated.
I am just not too sure there is a plant they will not eat at some time.
In the mean time I am working with lavendar, rubeckia, many, many varieties of sage and a lot of prayer!

Posted by:Patricia | July 27, 2009 at 07:32 PM

Large to XXL dogs. Trust me. One (or better yet two of) these will deter deer, bunnies and many other herbi-pests.

We have chickens, veggies, fruits, herbs and flowers in an unfenced yard in prime deer, rabbit etc. habitat - but we rarely see any damage. A few hundred pounds of dog regularly running loose in the yard (and sometimes successfully connecting with their predator heritage) seems to keep them in check.

YMMV.

Posted by:SmartDogs | August 02, 2009 at 09:27 PM

Patricia brings up a good point - deer, under the right circumstances, will eat practically anything. While the author of the article is correct in saying there are certain plants deer tend to find less appealing, betting the life of your garden on lists and hope might be too much. Important points - 1. There is no substitute for a good fence when it comes to deer control and garden protection and 2. Not all deer fencing is unsightly. In fact, Benner's Gardens (bennersgardens.com) sells a product that has been incredibly successful for years - what they call "Virtually Invisible" fencing...it can't be seen much past 15 feet, protecting your yard while not being an eyesore. I'd suggest readers of this article having trouble with deer should check out bennersgardens.com...if not for the products, then at least for all of the great free info about deer protection from a company that knows what it's talking about.

Posted by:Max | August 06, 2009 at 06:10 AM

By accident, I discovered that the deer
aren't eating roses near my blooming
catnip. Regular mint has never deterred them before so this is new.

Posted by:J Gifford | August 18, 2009 at 05:50 PM

I agree deer will eat anything they can get there hands on.

Also i have two large dogs and they have stopped rabbitts and deer, which is good as the fence i built is only short.

Posted by:Building Materials Supplies | September 08, 2009 at 05:27 AM

Check out the new book Creating A Deer Proof Garden
by peter Derano
great info

Posted by:john smythe | September 17, 2009 at 07:45 AM

I just bought the book Creating A Deer and Rabbit Proof Garden and love it!
Very informative
thank you for the recommendation

Posted by:Andrea | November 17, 2009 at 12:38 PM
Post a comment


 

Search This Blog
Advertisement